Let me give you an example of a bad argument:
“Inside [Sheeana's] head, the fascinating and ancient voice of Serena Butler once again bubbled up from deep within her Other Memories. Sheeana carried on her conversation aloud. “Tell me one thing: How can Serena Butler be among my ancestors?”
If you dig deep enough, I am there. Ancestor after ancestor, generation after generation…
Sheeana was not so easily convinced. “But Serena Butler’s only child was murdered by thinking machines. That was the trigger of the Jihad. You had no heirs, no other descendants. How can you be in my Other Memories, regardless of how far back I go?”
She looked up at the strange forms of the sandworms, as if the martyred woman’s face might be there.
Because, Serena said, I am. The ancient voice said no more, and Sheeana knew she would get no better answer.”
-Hunters of Dune, 278-279 (Herbert, Anderson)
“Because I am”???
Are you kidding me?
Separating ‘Because’ from ‘I am’ with a ‘Serena said’ isn’t going to fool anyone
What am I supposed to think about this as a reader?
Am I really supposed to read over that and say, “Oh, that makes sense”?
This is not an argument you put into literature unless you’re describing 4-7 year old children.
Frank Herbert, your son is ruining your legacy!
Also, now that you’re pretty much done writing the series and are now only pumping out crap like Paul of Dune, Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson, I would dearly like to see the original notes that Mr. Frank Herbert left behind. I don’t believe you when you say he wrote that crap about “The Enemy” and thinking machines and Omnius.
Because without that proof, you have no legitimacy. All you’re doing is bastardizing the series that Frank Herbert left behind in the hope of a few quick dollars. To be honest, a lot of the time I feel like I’m reading amateur fan fiction! Although I haven’t read Paul of Dune, the description on the inside jacket really does make it sound like fan fiction- “Ok ok, we all know what happened during Dune and Dune Messiah but what happened in between??” It’s useless!
Please contact me so I can give you an address to which you can send unaltered photocopies of Frank Herbert’s notes.















